ERi-TV Live |
ERi-TV News |
Home » News » VIDEO: Eritrea Timali Movie Review (Part 2)
Contributor: Semhar E
June 14, 2010
It is a good beginning, but this film is total failure according to the real actors, yesterday’s fighters. I think the problem I see is the film has broad title and narrow reflect. The real failure is quitting. But if the director producers and writers take this positive criticism I think they can come out brilliant next time. For now embrace the failure.
Ajoka Esaias Tseggai………….Anta jgna ab gonka alena..Nkd tray,,Naka daa men eyu kmkahalka…Warsay zbelka nska endika …Fanus brki lilo zbelka nska endika Lemin leminey zbelka nska endika….Bezi belabelow keytdahal haderaka…………..beja keytkulefena ndelyeka ena. agedasi eka.
it is great move for the young ERITREAN move production ,i like to thank to all those in the film and also
Esaias Tseggai for the great work you can't pleased every one great start ,
ATA TAY MATU WEDY HOOOO MY GOD MEBZHETOM SI ZEWKSU ENBER ZEBRATU ZEYLOU ETI AZERAREBA KE KEMY GEROM YOM ZEZARBU ? AB UROPA KAONKA KETSMOM KOLKAS KABOM HEHEM U ZEBLKA ATUM KULKUM RETO ZEHABEKUM NEKDEM AZERARBAKUM ATEBUKOUWO MO SUU RETOKUM TEKBALNT KEHLUWO
KALE ZEBLO KA EMO NESKUM TEGADELTI KEMZI ESYAS TEGAY ZEGBRO KOMU KULU ZEHALFKUMO AB TESHUF AKRIBKUM KEM NATU FETUNU MO SUU RETOKUM TEHBUNA
ANE BEWGNEY FILM TEMALI BETAMI FETYAN ADNIKYAN YE KEGZA WEN YE .
KALE KERSO ZEYDELI ESYASE TEGAY AJOKA BERTE DONT GIVE UP BE STRONG.
Ab gonili aleku semhar..especially ab Sdet konka..I don't get them at all. First of all they are not artist they are just fighters how come a fighter critisize an anrtist because he/She was there. I am eritrean lady Was in the EPLF now in USA. I believe the story. I hate the ladies who are talking in Media. Snesrat gbera mejemrya..Adnka absnesrat. Ok. Dahar rietoka tgelxi. Hanti mo mka wenchercher eya tbl nera. Mehfer. PLS Eri TV iskatkum eyu gegenatat. Ezi natatkum Akmi eyu zgelzx. Nhade babi artist zteserh film bekolut highschool Ketegemgmwo. Shame on u Erit tv. Who is responsible for that. Esak mahari Or Mana kidana. Please.
BIJEKAY ZIFELT YELBON ZIBELKUKA TIRAY GIBER SIK BEL HALEWLEW AYTIBEL ZIAYNETU RIETO MORAL SEB ZEYHILWU HANGOLIMATAT_____BIRAVO ESEYAS STEGAY EDMEN TIENAN NIAKA KEMAKA ERITRAWI BRO BIMIRKABEY NIAMLAK YEMESGIN
wowow ata kindey melhasegna eyu zelo eba.kulom gedili kezi aynebren yiblu kulatna eko tegadelti ena nernan zelenan.tebayat nay seb ab gedli zitefelaleye eyu neru ezi kea nay amlak tefetro eyu.kulu ab gedli zinebere tiuy malet ayneberen buzuhat jeganu nerom buzuhat kea hakayat nerom.nay hager fikiri hadiruwom ziwetsu nerom kab zegatemom tsegemat kihadmu elom zisilefu nerom, nab sudan kihadmu zitahazu nerom tegefifom zimetsu nerom silezi hade seabay tray tsibuk tezaribu ember kaliot b filay kea eten awalid kulen wechmadat eyen zimesla buzuh haki ab timali riena alena kabti b akal zegatimena zinebre kea eyu silezi kulu shefinka tegadalay ambesa eyu neru elka mimidar haki aymeslenin.issayas kea b teami ambsa eka keep it up
antum weqesti weyodea yeberateo ykewn ember eza film iko hade kefal nayti znebere hiwet eyu teqisu areisti gn ane intay mmerezkula
timali is one of the best futrue eritrean movie.i watched all the comments but some of most of them are talkn abt the negative parts of the movie.ane kem alem meten eta movie bitaemi sibikti eya nera buzuh hakitat dima alewa.zibezuhu tegadelti neber eti tebayat kemu ayneberen elom rieyto kihibu riye aleku.sebat zitefelaley tebay alewom silezu kulu tegatalay wufuy tebae hurkut eyu neru kinbil aynikilin ena mikniyatu zitefelaleyu sebay zitefelaleye tebayat alewom ezi kea ab timali tekalihu alo.ezi kemzi ayneberen elka n buzuhat sebat ziseruhuwo haki mintsag kea kubul aykonen.at last issayas tsegay is one of the best writers in eritrea and i hope to hear the coments frm him too
ezia filim dihri 19 amet wala hade seb fetinwa zeyfelit isayas gemirwa esu kea mis gemera eti hasibuwo seyfelit seb wereja koynka rieto mihab btiami yehifir eyu mejemeriya moral habuwo shuu nab nekefeta mikad kaliay kea artist zkonu sebat eyom rieto kihbu zigbiom enber tegadalay slezikone tray rieto kihib yeblun any way issayas don't give up ma nigga keep it up (Jigna)
Indeed the movie had major problems, but that doesn't make it a total failure.I think the main problems were as follows;
1. The title was a big problem.Timali was a very broad title and audiences expected it to cover the entire 3 generation war. Instead the movie only focused on 3 people (freta, kibrab and yordanos).It didn't even cover the 1st generation (meaning the italian era) or the 3rd generation (warsay era). it only covered 14 yrs of EPLF history.
2. The theme of the movie and title don't go togthere. i found the movie to be a romance movie than historic movie. it only focused on the love story of (freta, kibrab and yordanos) and the author forgot to discuss history. it touched on the hardships and the sufferings the soldiers faced, but never in detail.Audiences again, because of the title, expected it to be discuss all those historic events,living conditions of tegadelti and battles in detail, but it fell short.
3.Eventhough the movie was a romance movie,i couldn't tell if kibrab was in love with freta as much as with yordanos. even when he talks with freta ,he always brought up yordanos and seems that he loved her more than he ever felt anything for freta. i actually felt, even after watching the movie again, he married freta because she was in love with him and that he wanted to be nice to her.
Regardless, i would not say the movie was a total failure.By the way i liked the ending because it thought the audience two good lessons.i'm glad the author included these two points in the movie.
1. Marriage is once and for all. so when kibrab choose his wife freta over his ex-girlfriend yordanos, it taught people the value of marriage.
2. The consequences of teenage pregnancy. yordanos got pregnant and she lost everything including kibrab and became a single mother at such a young age. she also lost her chance to join the soldiers at the battle field, to finish school and her reputation.
Anyways, this movie is a beginning not an end, and i think Eritrean authors will learn a lot from all the criticism of this movie and we will hopefully see better movies about our history soon.
hey guys i wach all the part of the movies its was good but same part the way they speak tegadelty its true no respect just like aty more serfea we know all this yah but the way of gedly nonooooooooooooo its like loves's story any how its Great movie esais thanx
@ hana you are Amazing. You hit the nail on the head. Perfect. That's what I was looking for. I am proud of you. We shouldn't be negative. The writer and director did something. You know what I mean. At least we need to appreciate him for his effort.Right?? And we shouldn't forget everyone makes a mistke though ESAIAS TSEGGAI is the legend
bzaba film timali bzuh riton gemgamat entetwahbe eqau aziu smietawi sm derasayn senay tebegson zekshamshn serahtu fetsemtun bhiwet enkelena kinhitet nera kinwasae nerna behalti koynu ysmaani ab rietoombelu gignnet kian gedli eritreanas tsihifkum aytwdwon ekum emo kab nekefti tkonu tfelto zfetsemkumo gignnet sle zikonkum enho medan feresn emo haye kidmi kabza alem mflaykum nderestna akaflu ab microphone keribka nekafi kab mikan fltetka mkifal yhaysh
debiat cab canada
The thing is the tittle is too big, but the movie is an excellent one. Emotional comment of some viewers is killing this movie. This movie is about one line of life, but all of them are blaming it for not representing their own line of life. For me, Most of it has happened in gedli. Freta being smoking is the key issue here, but I know one tegadalit who had this life, and she had a big position during strugle and she still has top position. Besides I don't think most of viewers heard the comentary part wedi sergenti was given during the struggle. Offcourse we can see the financial and logistic problem, which we have to work on, but overall the movie is a good start, we have to help them…
I believe this movie is a continuation or different vantage point of lookiing at the other movie the great Isayas tsegai called "Fikrin Kuinatn" translated as War and Love…. I think isayas was just trying to expand on that movie rather than trace the past experience as uptly the title of the movie would suggest. So, though the movie have great story to tell, because what ever you see there was somehow an experience too!!!! however the title has shifted the expectation was off that some showed displeasure with the presentation of the move. As to me, I greatly enjoyed the move and the move sent me back to the days and helped me connect dots to see the bigger picture. I guess that is what a movie supposed to do after all. the motive of the director though, can better be explained if one saw the other movie by the same director called Love and War!!!!
Eseyas Tsegay deserves praise for his great work on the series film Timali. In the review many people criticized him harshly and some undermined him as if he knows nothing. I did not expect such harsh critisizm from many x-fighters. The narrator Kibreab has narrated almost every annals from the period of coloniality until Eritrea`s liberation. As criticizers, they should see the big picture instead of telling trifling issue.Try to examine what the writer wants to say.
The good part of the film is that it reflect the real human behavior whether they were Tegadelti, Hafash, Kedeat or someone. No movie ever produced in Eritrea as good as Timali. The film is rich in language, poignant, very entertaining and has great message for those who understand.
Atum sebat ezia film ezia mebegesitn meharitn koyna btaimi zbiqti eya eye zbla: Kulu nay selasa amet gedli tarik bezi zelo aqmis kemey geyru bhade film kznto ykeal: Entekielkum Eseyas Tsegay anfet hibkum alo btewesaki nskum kea neti haguaf alewa awaldna kemzi ayneberan:eti znebere tmyet aytegelzen: wedo geba ab 77/78 kemu aygeberun tbliwo zelekum kulu amehayshkum hanti abay nay 30 amet tarik gedli Eritrea tgelz film ktserhu mebegesit film tmali koynatkum ala haye ajokum edin guantin konkum ktserhu tebegesu:: Eseyas Tsegay kea ajoka btaemi zbqti film" timali" nata tarik zhazelet xbqtn niedtn film eye zbla:: Be proud of yourself !! Kab hanti teazabit
guys it is a good start!!!!!!!!!! Isaya tsegay is really genius. To crisitize is a very simple thing but to do some great jobs like timali is very difficult so plz lets praise isaya the great. we will wait more from him.
(Will not be published)
EriTV LIVE |
Music 1 |
Comedy | Audio |
Social Networking |
Travel | Sports | A&E |
Amharic Music |
Amharic News |
Amharic News 2 |
Shingrwa | EEBC | Development | EDF | Hizbawi Mekete | PIA |
PIA 2 |
May 24th Fest | Education | Healthcare | Artist Interview